
Genre redefining, a phrase often thrown about but rarely lived up to. In the case of Christopher Nolan's
Batman a solid, visionary and even literary minded director applied myth with modern noir to create a 'realistic' super hero. Sure
Watchmen set the graphic novel standard for a world where super heroes were real, but Nolan's interpretation of Gotham's vigilante effectively intertwined our own world into the mythic.
I think the treatment of the Joker in
The Dark Knight is the best example. Heath Ledger's turn as the mad killer, a demented demolitionist, a true living breathing anarchist (which is what I always interpreted the Joker to be) made it that much more real.
Now, with
Thor ramping up casting and pre-production, word comes from Kenneth Branagh's set that this movie could once again change the genre. Why? Well, after a recent visit to Branagh's Thor think-tank, Marvel Comics Editor-in-Chief Joe Quesada could not contain his excitement.
Telling Comic Book Resources
Cup O' Joe, "You can never really predict 100% success, but at this juncture, 'Thor' does seem to have all the ingredients in place to make it huge so its foundation feels very strong to me."
Quesada, Marvel's first artist Editor-in-Chief, also notes, "If you're a comics fan, you'll have a preconceived notion of what you're going to get. If you're a non-comics fan, you'll have another notion of what the movie is all about. And what's really amazing is that both groups will walk away going, 'I've never seen anything like this before within the super hero genre.'"
These are potently optimistic words and I think if you were to read into the latter comments, they come into context when factoring in Branagh.
The veteran actor and director has gravitas in both professions, a solid Irish/English theatrical pedigree and a sense for classics. His take on
Henry V is a classic of Shakespeare on the screen,
Dead Again an edgy thriller tale and the much maligned
Frankenstein was still a solid take on the Shelley classic. He has shown the skill as director, leaping about genres. Same skills demonstrated as an actor in everything from comedy to Shakespeare.
And while I loved
Iron Man, owning a copy and eagerly awaiting the sequel, director John Favreau is a lunch-pale type of director. He is the skilled carpenter that builds you a solid, comfortable home, but not a craftsman bungalow that nurtures your soul.
Branagh however is a director that could potentially create a classic tale of adventure, mixing myths from antiquity to today, utilizing the old gods of Europe for mood and setting, while piecing together the best elements of Marvel's Nordic super hero multiverse.
Ultimately Queseda may be preparing, to the best of his ability, the ravenous comic book fans for a different take on their beloved Thor. As we saw with 'the squid' in Watchmen, fans can be very fickle when it comes to an iconic story, character or 'key' plot element. Maybe the winged helmet goes. Maybe a rugged beard is added more akin to a modern bad-ass Norwegian special operations soldier, or gone is the funny looking round plate armor get-up and cape? And what about
mjolnir?
Batman and
The Dark Knight worked because they utilized our classic modern myths, ie super heroes, in a world that was accessible, just off center and real. Tangible. Too many CGI-fests are so removed from reality, that no matter how fantastic the story or universe, the story seems less than genuine and artificial.
However, Branagh may choose to make this the foundation story of Thor, doing battle in a realm of fantasy, gods and monsters, before plummeting the erstwhile Thunder god to Earth. Or, the flick could be a combination of both.
All around, with Branagh at the wheel of this ship, I feel like we could be in for an interesting and mythic tale.